{-# OPTIONS --allow-unsolved-metas #-}

open import Level
open import Ordinals
module Topology {n : Level } (O : Ordinals {n})   where

open import zf
open import logic
open _∧_
open _∨_
open Bool

import OD
open import Relation.Nullary
open import Data.Empty
open import Relation.Binary.Core
open import Relation.Binary.Definitions
open import Relation.Binary.PropositionalEquality
import BAlgebra
open BAlgebra O
open inOrdinal O
open OD O
open OD.OD
open ODAxiom odAxiom
import OrdUtil
import ODUtil
open Ordinals.Ordinals  O
open Ordinals.IsOrdinals isOrdinal
open Ordinals.IsNext isNext
open OrdUtil O
open ODUtil O

import ODC
open ODC O

open import filter O
open import OPair O

record Topology  ( L : HOD ) : Set (suc n) where
   field
       OS    : HOD
       OS⊆PL :  OS ⊆ Power L
       o∩ : { p q : HOD } → OS ∋ p →  OS ∋ q      → OS ∋ (p ∩ q)
       o∪ : { P : HOD }  →  P ⊆ OS                → OS ∋ Union P
       OS∋od∅ : OS ∋ od∅
--- we may add
--     OS∋L   :  OS ∋ L
-- closed Set
   CS : HOD
   CS = record { od = record { def = λ x → (* x ⊆ L) ∧ odef OS (& ( L ＼ (* x ))) } ; odmax = osuc (& L) ; <odmax = tp02 } where
       tp02 : {y : Ordinal } → (* y ⊆ L) ∧ odef OS (& (L ＼ * y)) → y o< osuc (& L)
       tp02 {y} nop = subst (λ k → k o≤ & L ) &iso ( ⊆→o≤ (λ {x} yx → proj1 nop yx ))
   os⊆L :  {x : HOD} → OS ∋ x → x ⊆ L
   os⊆L {x} Ox {y} xy = ( OS⊆PL Ox ) _ (subst (λ k → odef k y) (sym *iso) xy  )
   cs⊆L :  {x : HOD} → CS ∋ x → x ⊆ L
   cs⊆L {x} Cx {y} xy = proj1 Cx (subst (λ k → odef k y ) (sym *iso) xy )
   CS∋L : CS ∋ L
   CS∋L = ⟪ subst (λ k → k ⊆ L) (sym *iso) (λ x → x)  , subst (λ k → odef OS (& k)) (sym lem0) OS∋od∅  ⟫ where
        lem0 : L ＼ * (& L) ≡ od∅
        lem0 = subst (λ k → L ＼ k  ≡ od∅) (sym *iso) L＼L=0
   CS⊆PL :  CS ⊆ Power L
   CS⊆PL {x} Cx y xy = proj1 Cx xy
   P＼CS=OS : {cs : HOD} → CS ∋ cs →  OS ∋ ( L ＼ cs )
   P＼CS=OS {cs} ⟪ cs⊆L , olcs  ⟫ = subst (λ k → odef OS k) (cong (λ k → & ( L ＼ k)) *iso)  olcs
   P＼OS=CS : {cs : HOD} → OS ∋ cs →  CS ∋ ( L ＼ cs )
   P＼OS=CS {os} oos = ⟪ subst (λ k → k ⊆ L) (sym *iso) proj1
      , subst (λ k → odef OS k) (cong (&) (trans (sym (L＼Lx=x (os⊆L oos))) (cong (λ k → L ＼ k) (sym *iso)) )) oos  ⟫

open Topology

-- Closure ( Intersection of Closed Set which include A )

Cl : {L : HOD} → (top : Topology L) → (A : HOD) → HOD
Cl {L} top A = record { od = record { def = λ x → odef L x ∧ ( (c : Ordinal) → odef (CS top) c → A ⊆ * c → odef (* c) x ) }
  ; odmax = & L ; <odmax = odef∧< }

ClL : {L : HOD} → (top : Topology L) → Cl top L  ≡ L
ClL {L} top  =  ==→o≡ ( record { eq→ = λ {x} ic
        → subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso ((proj2 ic) (& L) (CS∋L top) (subst (λ k → L ⊆ k) (sym *iso) ( λ x → x)))
    ; eq← =  λ {x} lx → ⟪ lx , ( λ c cs l⊆c → l⊆c lx) ⟫ } )

-- Closure is Closed Set

CS∋Cl : {L : HOD} → (top : Topology L) → (A : HOD) → CS top ∋ Cl top A 
CS∋Cl {L} top A = subst (λ k → CS top ∋ k) (==→o≡ cc00) (P＼OS=CS top UOCl-is-OS)  where
    OCl : HOD  -- set of open set which it not contains A 
    OCl = record { od = record { def = λ o → odef (OS top) o ∧ ( A ⊆ (L ＼ * o) ) } ; odmax = & (OS top) ; <odmax = odef∧< }
    OCl⊆OS  : OCl ⊆  OS top 
    OCl⊆OS ox  = proj1 ox
    UOCl-is-OS : OS top ∋ Union OCl
    UOCl-is-OS = o∪ top OCl⊆OS
    cc00 : (L ＼ Union OCl) =h= Cl top A
    cc00 = record { eq→ = cc01 ; eq← = cc03 } where
        cc01 : {x : Ordinal} → odef (L ＼ Union OCl) x → odef L x ∧ ((c : Ordinal) → odef (CS top) c → A ⊆ * c → odef (* c) x)
        cc01 {x} ⟪ Lx , nul ⟫ = ⟪ Lx , ( λ c cc ac → cc02 c cc ac nul ) ⟫ where 
           cc02 : (c : Ordinal) → odef (CS top) c → A ⊆ * c → ¬ odef (Union OCl) x  → odef (* c) x
           cc02 c cc ac nox with ODC.∋-p O (* c) (* x)
           ... | yes y = subst (λ k → odef (* c) k) &iso y
           ... | no ncx = ⊥-elim ( nox record { owner = & ( L ＼ * c) ; ao = ⟪ proj2 cc , cc07 ⟫ ; ox = subst (λ k → odef k x) (sym *iso) cc06  } ) where
                cc06 : odef (L ＼ * c) x 
                cc06 = ⟪ Lx , subst (λ k → ¬ odef (* c) k) &iso ncx ⟫
                cc08 : * c ⊆ L
                cc08 = cs⊆L top (subst (λ k → odef (CS top) k ) (sym &iso) cc )
                cc07 :  A ⊆ (L ＼ * (& (L ＼ * c)))
                cc07 {z} az = subst (λ k → odef k z ) (
                   begin  * c ≡⟨ sym ( L＼Lx=x cc08 ) ⟩
                   L ＼ (L ＼ * c) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → L ＼ k ) (sym *iso) ⟩
                   L ＼ * (& (L ＼ * c)) ∎ ) ( ac az ) where open ≡-Reasoning
        cc03 : {x : Ordinal}  → odef L x ∧ ((c : Ordinal) → odef (CS top) c → A ⊆ * c → odef (* c) x) → odef (L ＼ Union OCl) x
        cc03 {x} ⟪ Lx , ccx ⟫ = ⟪ Lx , cc04 ⟫ where
           -- if x is in Cl A, it is in some c : CS, OCl says it is not , i.e. L ＼ o ∋ x, so it is in (L ＼ Union OCl) x
           cc04 : ¬ odef (Union OCl) x
           cc04 record { owner = o ; ao = ⟪ oo , A⊆L-o ⟫ ; ox = ox } = proj2 ( subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso cc05) ox  where
                cc05 : odef (* (& (L ＼ * o))) x
                cc05 = ccx (& (L ＼ * o)) (P＼OS=CS top (subst (λ k → odef (OS top) k) (sym &iso) oo)) (subst (λ k → A ⊆ k) (sym *iso) A⊆L-o) 


-- Subbase P
--   A set of countable intersection of P will be a base (x ix an element of the base)

data Subbase (P : HOD) : Ordinal → Set n where
   gi : {x : Ordinal } → odef P x → Subbase P x
   g∩ : {x y : Ordinal } → Subbase P x → Subbase P y → Subbase P (& (* x ∩ * y))

--
--   if y is in a Subbase, some element of P contains it

sbp :  (P : HOD) {x : Ordinal } → Subbase P x → Ordinal
sbp P {x} (gi {y} px) = x
sbp P {.(& (* _ ∩ * _))} (g∩ sb sb₁) = sbp P sb

is-sbp :  (P : HOD) {x y : Ordinal } → (px : Subbase P x) → odef (* x) y  → odef P (sbp P px ) ∧ odef (* (sbp P px)) y
is-sbp P {x} (gi px) xy = ⟪ px , xy ⟫
is-sbp P {.(& (* _ ∩ * _))} (g∩ {x} {y} px px₁) xy = is-sbp P px (proj1 (subst (λ k → odef k _ ) *iso  xy))

sb⊆ : {P Q : HOD} {x : Ordinal } → P ⊆ Q → Subbase P x → Subbase Q x
sb⊆ {P} {Q} P⊆Q (gi px) = gi (P⊆Q px)
sb⊆ {P} {Q} P⊆Q (g∩ px qx) = g∩ (sb⊆ P⊆Q px) (sb⊆ P⊆Q qx)

--  An open set generate from a base
--
--  OS = { U ⊆ L | ∀ x ∈ U → ∃ b ∈ P →  x ∈ b ⊆ U }

record Base (L P : HOD) (u x : Ordinal) : Set n where
   field
       b   : Ordinal
       u⊆L : * u ⊆ L
       sb  : Subbase P b
       b⊆u : * b ⊆ * u
       bx  : odef (* b) x
   x⊆L : odef L x
   x⊆L = u⊆L (b⊆u bx)

SO : (L P : HOD) → HOD
SO L P = record { od = record { def = λ u → {x : Ordinal } → odef (* u) x → Base L P u x } ; odmax = osuc (& L) ; <odmax = tp00 } where
    tp00 :  {y : Ordinal} → ({x : Ordinal} → odef (* y) x → Base L P y x) → y o< osuc (& L)
    tp00 {y} op = subst (λ k → k o≤ & L ) &iso ( ⊆→o≤ (λ {x} yx → Base.x⊆L (op yx) ))

record IsSubBase (L P : HOD) : Set (suc n) where
   field
       P⊆PL   : P ⊆ Power L
--  we may need these if OS ∋ L is necessary
--     p    : {x : HOD} → L ∋ x → HOD
--     Pp   : {x : HOD} → {lx : L ∋ x } → P ∋ p lx
--     px   : {x : HOD} → {lx : L ∋ x } → p lx ∋ x

InducedTopology : (L P : HOD) → IsSubBase L P  → Topology L
InducedTopology L P isb = record { OS = SO L P ; OS⊆PL = tp00
         ; o∪ = tp02 ; o∩ = tp01 ; OS∋od∅ = tp03 } where
    tp03 : {x : Ordinal } → odef (* (& od∅)) x → Base L P (& od∅) x
    tp03 {x} 0x = ⊥-elim ( empty (* x) ( subst₂ (λ j k → odef j k ) *iso (sym &iso) 0x ))
    tp00 : SO L P ⊆ Power L
    tp00 {u} ou x ux  with ou ux
    ... | record { b = b ; u⊆L = u⊆L ; sb = sb ; b⊆u = b⊆u ; bx = bx } = u⊆L (b⊆u bx)
    tp01 :  {p q : HOD} → SO L P ∋ p → SO L P ∋ q → SO L P ∋ (p ∩ q)
    tp01 {p} {q} op oq {x} ux =  record { b = b ; u⊆L = subst (λ k → k ⊆ L) (sym *iso) ul
      ; sb = g∩ (Base.sb (op px)) (Base.sb (oq qx))   ; b⊆u = tp08 ; bx = tp14 } where
        px : odef (* (& p)) x
        px = subst (λ k → odef k x ) (sym *iso) ( proj1 (subst (λ k → odef k _ ) *iso ux ) )
        qx : odef (* (& q)) x
        qx = subst (λ k → odef k x ) (sym *iso) ( proj2 (subst (λ k → odef k _ ) *iso ux ) )
        b : Ordinal
        b = & (* (Base.b (op px)) ∩ * (Base.b (oq qx)))
        tp08 :  * b ⊆ * (& (p ∩ q) )
        tp08 =  subst₂ (λ j k → j ⊆ k ) (sym *iso)  (sym *iso) (⊆∩-dist {(* (Base.b (op px)) ∩ * (Base.b (oq qx)))} {p} {q} tp09 tp10 ) where
             tp11 : * (Base.b (op px))  ⊆ * (& p )
             tp11 = Base.b⊆u (op px)
             tp12 : * (Base.b (oq qx))  ⊆ * (& q )
             tp12 = Base.b⊆u (oq qx)
             tp09 : (* (Base.b (op px)) ∩ * (Base.b (oq qx))) ⊆ p
             tp09 = ⊆∩-incl-1 {* (Base.b (op px))} {* (Base.b (oq qx))} {p} (subst (λ k → (* (Base.b (op px))) ⊆ k ) *iso tp11)
             tp10 : (* (Base.b (op px)) ∩ * (Base.b (oq qx))) ⊆ q
             tp10 = ⊆∩-incl-2 {* (Base.b (oq qx))} {* (Base.b (op px))} {q} (subst (λ k → (* (Base.b (oq qx))) ⊆ k ) *iso tp12)
        tp14 : odef (* (& (* (Base.b (op px)) ∩ * (Base.b (oq qx))))) x
        tp14 = subst (λ k → odef k x ) (sym *iso) ⟪ Base.bx (op px) , Base.bx (oq qx) ⟫
        ul :  (p ∩ q) ⊆ L
        ul = subst (λ k → k ⊆ L ) *iso (λ {z} pq →  (Base.u⊆L (op px)) (pz pq) )  where
            pz : {z : Ordinal } → odef (* (& (p ∩ q))) z → odef (* (& p)) z
            pz {z} pq = subst (λ k → odef k z ) (sym *iso) ( proj1 (subst (λ k → odef k _ ) *iso pq ) )
    tp02 : { q : HOD} → q ⊆ SO L P → SO L P ∋ Union q
    tp02 {q} q⊆O {x} ux with subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso ux
    ... | record { owner = y ; ao = qy ; ox = yx } with q⊆O qy yx
    ... | record { b = b ; u⊆L = u⊆L ; sb = sb ; b⊆u = b⊆u ; bx = bx } = record { b = b ; u⊆L = subst (λ k → k ⊆ L) (sym *iso) tp04
           ; sb = sb ; b⊆u = subst ( λ k → * b ⊆ k ) (sym *iso) tp06  ; bx = bx } where
        tp05 :  Union q ⊆ L
        tp05 {z} record { owner = y ; ao = qy ; ox = yx } with q⊆O qy yx
        ... | record { b = b ; u⊆L = u⊆L ; sb = sb ; b⊆u = b⊆u ; bx = bx }
           = IsSubBase.P⊆PL isb (proj1 (is-sbp P sb bx )) _ (proj2 (is-sbp P sb bx ))
        tp04 :  Union q ⊆ L
        tp04 = tp05
        tp06 : * b ⊆ Union q
        tp06 {z} bz = record { owner = y ; ao = qy ; ox = b⊆u bz  }

-- Product Topology

open ZFProduct

-- Product Topology is not
--     ZFP (OS TP) (OS TQ) (box)

record BaseP {P : HOD} (TP : Topology P ) (Q : HOD) (x : Ordinal) : Set n where
   field
       p : Ordinal
       op : odef (OS TP) p
       prod : x ≡ & (ZFP (* p) Q )

record BaseQ (P : HOD) {Q : HOD} (TQ : Topology Q ) (x : Ordinal) : Set n where
   field
       q  : Ordinal
       oq : odef (OS TQ) q
       prod : x ≡ & (ZFP P (* q ))

pbase⊆PL : {P Q : HOD} → (TP : Topology P) → (TQ : Topology Q) → {x : Ordinal } → BaseP TP Q x ∨ BaseQ P TQ x → odef (Power (ZFP P Q)) x
pbase⊆PL {P} {Q} TP TQ {z} (case1 record { p = p ; op = op ; prod = prod }) = subst (λ k → odef (Power (ZFP P Q)) k ) (sym prod) tp01  where
    tp01 : odef (Power (ZFP P Q)) (& (ZFP (* p) Q))
    tp01 w wz with subst (λ k → odef k w ) *iso wz
    ... | ab-pair {a} {b} pa qb = ZFP→ (subst (λ k → odef P k ) (sym &iso) tp03 ) (subst (λ k → odef Q k ) (sym &iso) qb ) where
        tp03 : odef P a
        tp03 =  os⊆L TP (subst (λ k → odef (OS TP) k) (sym &iso) op) pa
pbase⊆PL {P} {Q} TP TQ {z} (case2 record { q = q ; oq = oq ; prod = prod }) = subst (λ k → odef (Power (ZFP P Q)) k ) (sym prod) tp01  where
    tp01 : odef (Power (ZFP P Q)) (& (ZFP P (* q) ))
    tp01 w wz with subst (λ k → odef k w ) *iso wz
    ... | ab-pair {a} {b} pa qb = ZFP→ (subst (λ k → odef P k ) (sym &iso) pa ) (subst (λ k → odef Q k ) (sym &iso) tp03 )  where
        tp03 : odef Q b
        tp03 =  os⊆L TQ (subst (λ k → odef (OS TQ) k) (sym &iso) oq) qb

pbase : {P Q : HOD} → Topology P → Topology Q → HOD
pbase {P} {Q} TP TQ = record { od = record { def = λ x → BaseP TP Q x ∨ BaseQ P TQ x } ; odmax = & (Power (ZFP P Q)) ; <odmax = tp00 } where
    tp00 : {y : Ordinal} → BaseP TP Q y ∨ BaseQ P TQ y → y o< & (Power (ZFP P Q))
    tp00 {y} bpq = odef< ( pbase⊆PL TP TQ bpq )

ProductTopology : {P Q : HOD} → Topology P → Topology Q → Topology (ZFP P Q)
ProductTopology {P} {Q} TP TQ =  InducedTopology (ZFP P Q) (pbase TP TQ) record { P⊆PL = pbase⊆PL TP TQ }

-- covers  ( q ⊆ Union P )

record _covers_ ( P q : HOD  ) : Set n where
   field
       cover   : {x : Ordinal } → odef q x → Ordinal
       P∋cover : {x : Ordinal } → (lt : odef q  x) → odef P (cover lt)
       isCover : {x : Ordinal } → (lt : odef q  x) → odef (* (cover lt))  x

open _covers_

-- Finite Intersection Property

record FIP {L : HOD} (top : Topology L) : Set n where
   field
       limit : {X : Ordinal } → * X ⊆ CS top
          →       ( { C : Ordinal  } { x : Ordinal } → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x ) →  Ordinal
       is-limit : {X : Ordinal } → (CX : * X ⊆ CS top )
          → ( fip : { C : Ordinal  } { x : Ordinal } → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x )
          →  {x : Ordinal } → odef (* X) x → odef (* x) (limit CX fip)
   L∋limit  : {X : Ordinal } → (CX : * X ⊆ CS top )
          → ( fip : { C : Ordinal  } { x : Ordinal } → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x )
          →  {x : Ordinal } → odef (* X) x
          →  odef L (limit CX fip)
   L∋limit {X} CX fip {x} xx = cs⊆L top (subst (λ k → odef (CS top) k) (sym &iso) (CX xx)) (is-limit CX fip xx)

fipx : {L : HOD} (top : Topology L) → {X : Ordinal } → * X ⊆ CS top
     →   ( { C : Ordinal  } { x : Ordinal } → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x ) →  Ordinal
fipx {L} top {X} X⊆CS fip with trio< X o∅ 
... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬x<0 a )
... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = o∅
... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = & (ODC.minimal O (* fip00) (0<P→ne (subst (λ k → o∅ o< k) (sym &iso) ( fip (λ x → x ) (gi ? ) )))) where
   fip00 : ?
   fip00 = & (ODC.minimal O (* X) (0<P→ne (subst (λ k → o∅ o< k) (sym &iso) c ) )) 

fipX∋x : {L : HOD} (top : Topology L) → {X : Ordinal } → (X⊆CS : * X ⊆ CS top )
     →   (fip : { C : Ordinal  } { x : Ordinal } → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x ) →  odef (* X) (fipx top X⊆CS fip)
fipX∋x {L} top {X} X⊆CS fip with trio< X o∅ 
... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬x<0 a )
... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ?
... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ? -- fip (λ x → x) (gi ?)

-- Compact

data Finite-∪ (S : HOD) : Ordinal → Set n where
   fin-e : {x : Ordinal } → * x ⊆ S → Finite-∪ S x
   fin-∪  : {x y : Ordinal } → Finite-∪ S x → Finite-∪ S y → Finite-∪ S (& (* x ∪ * y))

record Compact  {L : HOD} (top : Topology L)  : Set n where
   field
       finCover  : {X : Ordinal } → (* X) ⊆ OS top → (* X) covers L → Ordinal
       isCover   : {X : Ordinal } → (xo : (* X) ⊆ OS top) → (xcp : (* X) covers L ) → (* (finCover xo xcp )) covers L
       isFinite  : {X : Ordinal } → (xo : (* X) ⊆ OS top) → (xcp : (* X) covers L ) → Finite-∪ (* X) (finCover xo xcp )

-- FIP is Compact

FIP→Compact : {L : HOD} → (top : Topology L ) → FIP top  → Compact top
FIP→Compact {L} top fip with trio< (& L) o∅
... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬x<0 a )
... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = record { finCover = λ _ _ → o∅ ; isCover = λ {X} _ xcp → fip01 xcp ; isFinite = fip00 }  where
   -- L is empty
   fip02 : {x : Ordinal } → ¬ odef L x
   fip02 {x} Lx = ⊥-elim ( o<¬≡ (sym b) (∈∅< Lx) )
   fip01 : {X : Ordinal } → (xcp : * X covers L) → (* o∅) covers L
   fip01 xcp = record { cover = λ Lx → ⊥-elim (fip02 Lx)  ; P∋cover = λ Lx → ⊥-elim (fip02 Lx)  ; isCover =  λ Lx → ⊥-elim (fip02 Lx) }
   fip00 : {X : Ordinal} (xo : * X ⊆ OS top) (xcp : * X covers L) → Finite-∪ (* X) o∅
   fip00 {X} xo xcp = fin-e ( λ {x} 0x → ⊥-elim (¬x<0 (subst (λ k → odef k x) o∅≡od∅ 0x) ) )
... | tri> ¬a ¬b 0<L = record { finCover = finCover ; isCover = isCover1 ; isFinite = isFinite } where
   -- set of coset of X
   CX : {X : Ordinal} → * X ⊆ OS top → Ordinal
   CX {X} ox = & ( Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼  z ))
   CCX : {X : Ordinal} → (os :  * X ⊆ OS top) → * (CX os) ⊆ CS top
   CCX {X} os {x} ox with subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso ox
   ... | record { z = z ; az = az ; x=ψz = x=ψz } = ⟪ fip05 , fip06  ⟫ where --  x ≡ & (L ＼ * z)
      fip07 : z ≡ & (L ＼ * x)
      fip07 = subst₂ (λ j k → j ≡ k) &iso (cong (λ k → & ( L ＼ k )) (cong (*) (sym x=ψz))) ( cong (&) ( ==→o≡ record { eq→ = fip09 ; eq← = fip08 } )) where
          fip08 : {x : Ordinal} → odef L x ∧ (¬ odef (* (& (L ＼ * z))) x) → odef (* z) x
          fip08 {x} ⟪ Lx , not ⟫ with subst (λ k → (¬ odef k x)) *iso not -- ( odef L x ∧ odef (* z) x → ⊥) → ⊥
          ... | Lx∧¬zx = ODC.double-neg-elim O ( λ nz → Lx∧¬zx ⟪ Lx , nz ⟫ )
          fip09 : {x : Ordinal} → odef (* z) x → odef L x ∧ (¬ odef (* (& (L ＼ * z))) x)
          fip09 {w} zw = ⟪ os⊆L top (os (subst (λ k → odef (* X) k) (sym &iso) az)) zw  , subst (λ k → ¬ odef k w) (sym *iso) fip10   ⟫ where
             fip10 : ¬ (odef (L ＼ * z) w)
             fip10 ⟪ Lw , nzw ⟫ = nzw zw
      fip06 : odef (OS top) (& (L ＼ * x))
      fip06 = os ( subst (λ k → odef (* X) k ) fip07 az )
      fip05 : * x ⊆ L
      fip05 {w} xw = proj1 ( subst (λ k → odef k w) (trans (cong (*) x=ψz) *iso ) xw )
   --
   --   X covres L means Intersection of (CX X) contains nothing
   --     then some finite Intersection of (CX X) contains nothing ( contraposition of FIP .i.e. CFIP)
   --     it means there is a finite cover
   --
   record CFIP (X x : Ordinal) : Set n where
      field
         is-CS : * x ⊆ Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z)
         sx :  Subbase (* x)  o∅
   Cex : (X : Ordinal ) → HOD
   Cex X = record { od = record { def = λ x → CFIP X x } ; odmax = osuc (& (Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z))) ; <odmax = fip05 } where
       fip05 :  {y : Ordinal} →   CFIP X y → y o< osuc (& (Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z)))
       fip05 {y} cf = subst₂ (λ j k → j o< osuc k ) &iso refl ( ⊆→o≤ ( CFIP.is-CS cf ) )
   fip00 : {X : Ordinal } → * X ⊆ OS top → * X covers L → ¬ ( Cex X =h= od∅ )
   fip00 {X} ox oc cex=0 = ⊥-elim (fip09 fip25 fip20) where
       -- CX is finite intersection
       fip02 : {C x : Ordinal} → * C ⊆ * (CX ox) → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x
       fip02 {C} {x} C<CX sc with trio< x o∅
       ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬x<0 a )
       ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = c
       ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c  = ⊥-elim (¬x<0 ( _==_.eq→ cex=0 record { is-CS = fip10 ; sx = subst (λ k → Subbase (* C) k) b sc } )) where
           fip10 : * C ⊆ Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z)
           fip10 {w} cw = subst (λ k → odef k w) *iso ( C<CX cw )
       -- we have some intersection because L is not empty (if we have an element of L, we don't need choice)
       fip26 : odef (* (CX ox))    (& (L ＼  * ( cover oc ( ODC.x∋minimal O L (0<P→ne 0<L) ) )))
       fip26 = subst (λ k → odef k (& (L ＼  * ( cover oc ( ODC.x∋minimal O L (0<P→ne 0<L) ) )) )) (sym *iso)
          record { z = cover oc (x∋minimal L (0<P→ne 0<L)) ; az = P∋cover oc (x∋minimal L (0<P→ne 0<L))  ; x=ψz = refl }
       fip25 : odef L( FIP.limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 )
       fip25 = FIP.L∋limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 fip26
       fip20 : {y : Ordinal } → (Xy : odef (* X) y)  → ¬ ( odef (* y) ( FIP.limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 ))
       fip20 {y} Xy yl = proj2 fip21 yl where
           fip22 : odef (* (CX ox)) (& ( L ＼ * y ))
           fip22 = subst (λ k → odef k (& ( L ＼ * y ))) (sym *iso) record { z = y ; az = Xy ; x=ψz = refl }
           fip21 : odef (L ＼ * y) ( FIP.limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 )
           fip21 = subst (λ k → odef k ( FIP.limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 ) ) *iso ( FIP.is-limit fip (CCX ox) fip02 fip22 )
       fip09 : {z : Ordinal } →  odef L z → ¬ ( {y : Ordinal } → (Xy : odef (* X) y)  → ¬ ( odef (* y) z ))
       fip09 {z} Lz nc  =  nc ( P∋cover oc Lz  ) (subst (λ k → odef (* (cover oc Lz)) k) refl (isCover oc _ ))
   cex : {X : Ordinal } → * X ⊆ OS top → * X covers L → Ordinal
   cex {X} ox oc = & ( ODC.minimal O (Cex X) (fip00 ox oc))   -- this will be the finite cover
   CXfip : {X : Ordinal } → (ox : * X ⊆ OS top) → (oc : * X covers L) → CFIP X (cex ox oc)
   CXfip {X} ox oc  = ODC.x∋minimal O (Cex X) (fip00 ox oc)
   --
   -- this defines finite cover
   finCover :  {X : Ordinal} → * X ⊆ OS top → * X covers L → Ordinal
   finCover {X} ox oc = & ( Replace' (* (cex ox oc)) (λ z xz → L ＼  z ))
   -- create Finite-∪ from cex
   isFinite : {X : Ordinal} (xo : * X ⊆ OS top) (xcp : * X covers L) → Finite-∪ (* X) (finCover xo xcp)
   isFinite {X} xo xcp = fip30 (cex xo xcp) o∅ (CFIP.is-CS (CXfip xo xcp)) (CFIP.sx (CXfip xo xcp)) where
        fip30 : ( x y : Ordinal ) → * x ⊆ Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z) →  Subbase (* x) y → Finite-∪ (* X) (& (Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼  z )))
        fip30 x y x⊆cs (gi sb) = fip31 where
            fip32 : Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼ z) ⊆ * X --  x⊆cs :* x ⊆ Replace' (* X) (λ z₁ xz → L ＼ z₁) , x=ψz : w ≡ & (L ＼ * z) , odef (* x) z
            fip32 {w} record { z = z ; az = xz ; x=ψz = x=ψz } with x⊆cs xz
            ... | record { z = z1 ; az = az1 ; x=ψz = x=ψz1 } = subst (λ k → odef (* X) k) fip33 az1 where
               fip34 : * z1 ⊆ L
               fip34 {w} wz1 = os⊆L top (subst (λ k → odef (OS top) k) (sym &iso) (xo az1)) wz1
               fip33 : z1 ≡ w
               fip33 = begin
                 z1 ≡⟨ sym &iso ⟩
                 & (* z1) ≡⟨ cong (&) (sym  (L＼Lx=x fip34 )) ⟩
                 & (L ＼ ( L ＼ * z1)) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → & ( L ＼ k )) (sym *iso) ⟩
                 & (L ＼ * (& ( L ＼ * z1))) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → & ( L ＼ * k )) (sym x=ψz1) ⟩
                 & (L ＼ * z) ≡⟨ sym x=ψz ⟩
                 w ∎ where open ≡-Reasoning
            fip31 : Finite-∪ (* X) (& (Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼ z)))
            fip31 = fin-e (subst (λ k → k ⊆ * X ) (sym *iso) fip32 )
        fip30 x yz x⊆cs (g∩ {y} {z} sy sz) = fip35 where
            fip35 : Finite-∪ (* X) (& (Replace' (* x) (λ z₁ xz → L ＼ z₁)))
            fip35 = subst (λ k → Finite-∪ (* X) k)
               (cong (&) (subst (λ k → (k ∪ k ) ≡ (Replace' (* x) (λ z₁ xz → L ＼ z₁)) ) (sym *iso) x∪x≡x )) ( fin-∪ (fip30 _ _  x⊆cs sy)  (fip30 _ _ x⊆cs sz) )
   -- is also a cover
   isCover1 : {X : Ordinal} (xo : * X ⊆ OS top) (xcp : * X covers L) → * (finCover xo xcp) covers L
   isCover1 {X} xo xcp = subst₂ (λ j k → j covers k ) (sym *iso) (subst (λ k → L ＼ k ≡ L) (sym o∅≡od∅) L＼0=L)
     ( fip40 (cex xo xcp) o∅ (CFIP.is-CS (CXfip xo xcp)) (CFIP.sx (CXfip xo xcp))) where
        fip45 : {L a b : HOD} → (L ＼ (a ∩ b)) ⊆ ( (L ＼ a) ∪  (L ＼ b))
        fip45 {L} {a} {b} {x} Lab with ODC.∋-p O b (* x)
        ... | yes bx = case1 ⟪ proj1 Lab , (λ ax → proj2 Lab ⟪ ax , subst (λ k → odef b k) &iso bx ⟫ )  ⟫
        ... | no ¬bx = case2 ⟪ proj1 Lab , subst (λ k → ¬ ( odef b k)) &iso ¬bx  ⟫
        fip43 : {A L a b : HOD } → A covers (L ＼ a) → A covers (L ＼ b ) → A covers ( L ＼ ( a ∩ b ) )
        fip43 {A} {L} {a} {b} ca cb = record { cover = fip44 ; P∋cover = fip46 ; isCover = fip47 } where
            fip44 :  {x : Ordinal} → odef (L ＼ (a ∩ b)) x → Ordinal
            fip44 {x} Lab with fip45 {L} {a} {b} Lab
            ... | case1 La = cover ca La
            ... | case2 Lb = cover cb Lb
            fip46 : {x : Ordinal} (lt : odef (L ＼ (a ∩ b)) x) → odef A (fip44 lt)
            fip46 {x} Lab with  fip45 {L} {a} {b} Lab
            ... | case1 La = P∋cover ca La
            ... | case2 Lb = P∋cover cb Lb
            fip47 : {x : Ordinal} (lt : odef (L ＼ (a ∩ b)) x) → odef (* (fip44 lt)) x
            fip47 {x} Lab with  fip45 {L} {a} {b} Lab
            ... | case1 La = isCover ca La
            ... | case2 Lb = isCover cb Lb
        fip40 : ( x y : Ordinal ) → * x ⊆ Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼ z) →  Subbase (* x) y
           → (Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼  z )) covers (L ＼ * y )
        fip40 x .(& (* _ ∩ * _)) x⊆r (g∩ {a} {b} sa sb) = subst (λ k → (Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼ z)) covers ( L ＼ k ) ) (sym *iso)
          ( fip43 {_} {L} {* a} {* b} fip41 fip42 ) where
            fip41 : Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼ z) covers (L ＼ * a)
            fip41 = fip40 x a x⊆r sa
            fip42 : Replace' (* x) (λ z xz → L ＼ z) covers (L ＼ * b)
            fip42 = fip40 x b x⊆r sb
        fip40 x y x⊆r (gi sb) with x⊆r sb
        ... | record { z = z ; az = az ; x=ψz = x=ψz } = record { cover = fip51 ; P∋cover = fip53 ; isCover = fip50 }where
            fip51 : {w : Ordinal} (Lyw : odef (L ＼ * y) w) → Ordinal
            fip51 {w} Lyw = z
            fip52 : {w : Ordinal} (Lyw : odef (L ＼ * y) w) → odef (* X) z
            fip52 {w} Lyw = az
            fip55 : * z ⊆ L
            fip55 {w} wz1 = os⊆L top (subst (λ k → odef (OS top) k) (sym &iso) (xo az)) wz1
            fip56 : * z ≡ L ＼ * y
            fip56 = begin
                * z ≡⟨ sym (L＼Lx=x fip55 ) ⟩
                L ＼ ( L ＼ * z ) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → L ＼ k) (sym *iso)  ⟩
                L ＼ * ( & ( L ＼ * z )) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → L ＼ * k) (sym x=ψz)  ⟩
                L ＼ * y ∎  where open ≡-Reasoning
            fip53 : {w : Ordinal} (Lyw : odef (L ＼ * y) w) → odef (Replace' (* x) (λ z₁ xz → L ＼ z₁)) z
            fip53 {w} Lyw = record { z = _ ; az = sb ; x=ψz = fip54 } where
               fip54 : z ≡ & ( L ＼ * y )
               fip54 = begin
                 z ≡⟨ sym &iso ⟩
                 & (* z) ≡⟨ cong (&) fip56 ⟩
                 & (L ＼ * y )
                 ∎ where open ≡-Reasoning
            fip50 : {w : Ordinal} (Lyw : odef (L ＼ * y) w) → odef (* z) w
            fip50 {w} Lyw = subst (λ k → odef k w ) (sym fip56) Lyw

Compact→FIP : {L : HOD} → (top : Topology L ) → Compact top  → FIP top
Compact→FIP {L} top fip with trio< (& L) o∅
... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬x<0 a )
... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = record { limit = ? ; is-limit = ? } 
... | tri> ¬a ¬b 0<L = record { limit = limit ; is-limit = fip00 } where
   -- set of coset of X
   OX : {X : Ordinal} → * X ⊆ CS top → Ordinal
   OX {X} ox = & ( Replace' (* X) (λ z xz → L ＼  z ))
   OOX : {X : Ordinal} → (cs :  * X ⊆ CS top) → * (OX cs) ⊆ OS top
   OOX {X} cs {x} ox with subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso ox
   ... | record { z = z ; az = az ; x=ψz = x=ψz } =  subst (λ k → odef (OS top) k) (sym x=ψz) ( P＼CS=OS top (cs comp01))  where
       comp01 : odef (* X) (& (* z))
       comp01 = subst (λ k → odef (* X) k) (sym &iso) az

   --   if all finite intersection of (OX X) contains something, 
   --   there is no finite cover. From Compactness, (OX X) is not a cover of L ( contraposition of Compact)
   --     it means there is a limit
   --
   Intersection : (X : Ordinal ) → o∅ o< X →  HOD   -- ∩ X
   Intersection X 0<X = record { od = record { def = λ x → {y : Ordinal} → odef (* X) y → odef (* y) x } ; odmax = osuc X ; <odmax = i00 } where
       i00 : {x : Ordinal} → ({y : Ordinal} → odef (* X) y → odef (* y) x) → x o< osuc X
       i00 {x} xy = begin
           x ≤⟨ ? ⟩
           X ∎ where open o≤-Reasoning O
   has-intersection : {X : Ordinal} (CX : * X ⊆ CS top) (fip : {C x : Ordinal} → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x) 
      →  ¬ (  Intersection X ? =h= od∅ )
   has-intersection {X} CX fip i=0 = ? where
       no-cover : ¬ ( (* (OX CX)) covers L ) 
       no-cover = ?
   limit : {X : Ordinal} (CX : * X ⊆ CS top) (fip : {C x : Ordinal} → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x) 
      → Ordinal
   limit = ?
   fip00 : {X : Ordinal} (CX : * X ⊆ CS top)
            (fip : {C x : Ordinal} → * C ⊆ * X → Subbase (* C) x → o∅ o< x)
            {x : Ordinal} → odef (* X) x → odef (* x) (limit CX fip )
   fip00 = ?


open Filter

-- Ultra Filter has limit point

record Neighbor {P : HOD} (TP : Topology P) (x v : Ordinal) : Set n where
   field
       u : Ordinal
       ou : odef (OS TP) u
       ux : odef (* u) x
       v⊆P : * v ⊆ P
       u⊆v : * u ⊆ * v

--
-- Neighbor on x is a Filter (on Power P)
--
NeighborF : {P : HOD} (TP : Topology P)  (x : Ordinal ) → Filter {Power P} {P} (λ x → x)
NeighborF {P} TP x = record { filter = NF ; f⊆L = NF⊆PP ; filter1 = f1 ; filter2 = f2 } where
    nf00 : {v : Ordinal } → Neighbor TP x v → odef (Power P) v
    nf00 {v} nei y vy = Neighbor.v⊆P nei vy
    NF : HOD
    NF = record { od = record { def = λ v → Neighbor TP x v } ; odmax = & (Power P) ; <odmax = λ lt → odef< (nf00 lt) }
    NF⊆PP : NF ⊆ Power P
    NF⊆PP = nf00 
    f1 : {p q : HOD} → Power P ∋ q → NF ∋ p → p ⊆ q → NF ∋ q
    f1 {p} {q} Pq Np p⊆q = record { u = Neighbor.u Np ; ou = Neighbor.ou Np ; ux = Neighbor.ux Np ; v⊆P = Pq _ ; u⊆v = f11 } where
        f11 :  * (Neighbor.u Np) ⊆ * (& q)
        f11 {x} ux = subst (λ k → odef k x ) (sym *iso) ( p⊆q (subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso (Neighbor.u⊆v Np ux)) )
    f2 : {p q : HOD} → NF ∋ p → NF ∋ q → Power P ∋ (p ∩ q) → NF ∋ (p ∩ q)
    f2 {p} {q} Np Nq Ppq = record { u = upq ; ou = ou ; ux = ux ; v⊆P = Ppq _ ; u⊆v = f20 } where
         upq : Ordinal
         upq = & ( * (Neighbor.u Np) ∩ * (Neighbor.u Nq) )
         ou : odef (OS TP) upq
         ou = o∩ TP (subst (λ k → odef (OS TP) k) (sym &iso) (Neighbor.ou Np)) (subst (λ k → odef (OS TP) k) (sym &iso) (Neighbor.ou Nq))
         ux :  odef (* upq) x
         ux = subst ( λ k → odef k x ) (sym *iso) ⟪ Neighbor.ux Np , Neighbor.ux Nq ⟫
         f20 : * upq ⊆ * (& (p ∩ q))
         f20 = subst₂ (λ j k → j ⊆ k ) (sym *iso) (sym *iso) ( λ {x} pq 
           → ⟪ subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso (Neighbor.u⊆v Np (proj1 pq))  , subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso (Neighbor.u⊆v Nq (proj2 pq)) ⟫  )

CAP : (P : HOD) {p q : HOD } → Power P ∋ p → Power P ∋ q → Power P ∋ (p ∩ q)
CAP P {p} {q} Pp Pq x pqx with subst (λ k → odef k x ) *iso pqx
... | ⟪ px , qx ⟫ = Pp _ (subst (λ k → odef k x) (sym *iso) px )

NEG : (P : HOD) {p : HOD } → Power P ∋ p → Power P ∋ (P ＼ p )
NEG P {p} Pp x vx with subst (λ k → odef k x) *iso vx
... | ⟪ Px , npx ⟫ = Px