changeset 722:b088fa199d3d

...
author Shinji KONO <kono@ie.u-ryukyu.ac.jp>
date Sun, 09 Apr 2023 17:15:42 +0900
parents 2abfce56523a
children 43180a01bfbe
files ModelChecking.agda hoareBinaryTree1.agda redBlackTreeHoare.agda
diffstat 3 files changed, 574 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) [+]
line wrap: on
line diff
--- a/ModelChecking.agda	Sun May 22 19:07:20 2022 +0900
+++ b/ModelChecking.agda	Sun Apr 09 17:15:42 2023 +0900
@@ -261,7 +261,7 @@
 
 -- state db ( binary tree of processes )
 
--- depth first ececution
+-- depth first execution
 
 -- verify temporal logic poroerries
 
--- /dev/null	Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000
+++ b/hoareBinaryTree1.agda	Sun Apr 09 17:15:42 2023 +0900
@@ -0,0 +1,572 @@
+module hoareBinaryTree1 where
+
+open import Level renaming (zero to Z ; suc to succ)
+
+open import Data.Nat hiding (compare)
+open import Data.Nat.Properties as NatProp
+open import Data.Maybe
+-- open import Data.Maybe.Properties
+open import Data.Empty
+open import Data.List
+open import Data.Product
+
+open import Function as F hiding (const)
+
+open import Relation.Binary
+open import Relation.Binary.PropositionalEquality
+open import Relation.Nullary
+open import logic
+
+
+_iso_ : {n : Level} {a : Set n} → ℕ → ℕ → Set
+d iso d' = (¬ (suc d ≤ d')) ∧ (¬ (suc d' ≤ d))
+
+iso-intro : {n : Level} {a : Set n} {x y : ℕ} → ¬ (suc x ≤ y) → ¬ (suc y ≤ x) → _iso_ {n} {a} x y
+iso-intro = λ z z₁ → record { proj1 = z ; proj2 = z₁ }
+
+--
+--
+--  no children , having left node , having right node , having both
+--
+data bt {n : Level} (A : Set n) : Set n where
+  leaf : bt A
+  node :  (key : ℕ) → (value : A) →
+    (left : bt A ) → (right : bt A ) → bt A
+
+node-key : {n : Level} {A : Set n} → bt A → Maybe ℕ
+node-key (node key _ _ _) = just key
+node-key _ = nothing
+
+node-value : {n : Level} {A : Set n} → bt A → Maybe A
+node-value (node _ value _ _) = just value
+node-value _ = nothing
+
+bt-depth : {n : Level} {A : Set n} → (tree : bt A ) → ℕ
+bt-depth leaf = 0
+bt-depth (node key value t t₁) = suc (Data.Nat._⊔_ (bt-depth t ) (bt-depth t₁ ))
+
+open import Data.Unit hiding ( _≟_ ;  _≤?_ ; _≤_)
+
+data treeInvariant {n : Level} {A : Set n} : (tree : bt A) → Set n where
+    t-leaf : treeInvariant leaf 
+    t-single : (key : ℕ) → (value : A) →  treeInvariant (node key value leaf leaf) 
+    t-right : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → (key < key₁) → treeInvariant (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂)
+       → treeInvariant (node key value leaf (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂)) 
+    t-left  : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → (key < key₁) → treeInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂)
+       → treeInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) leaf ) 
+    t-node  : {key key₁ key₂ : ℕ} → {value value₁ value₂ : A} → {t₁ t₂ t₃ t₄ : bt A} → (key < key₁) → (key₁ < key₂)
+       → treeInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂) 
+       → treeInvariant (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄)
+       → treeInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄)) 
+
+--
+--  stack always contains original top at end
+--
+data stackInvariant {n : Level} {A : Set n}  (key : ℕ) : (top orig : bt A) → (stack  : List (bt A)) → Set n where
+    s-single :  {tree0 : bt A} → stackInvariant key tree0 tree0 (tree0 ∷ [])
+    s-right :  {tree tree0 tree₁ : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ } → {v1 : A } → {st : List (bt A)} 
+        → key₁ < key  →  stackInvariant key (node key₁ v1 tree₁ tree) tree0 st → stackInvariant key tree tree0 (tree ∷ st)
+    s-left :  {tree₁ tree0 tree : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ } → {v1 : A } → {st : List (bt A)} 
+        → key  < key₁ →  stackInvariant key (node key₁ v1 tree₁ tree) tree0 st → stackInvariant key tree₁ tree0 (tree₁ ∷ st)
+
+data replacedTree  {n : Level} {A : Set n} (key : ℕ) (value : A)  : (before after : bt A ) → Set n where
+    r-leaf : replacedTree key value leaf (node key value leaf leaf)
+    r-node : {value₁ : A} → {t t₁ : bt A} → replacedTree key value (node key value₁ t t₁) (node key value t t₁) 
+    r-right : {k : ℕ } {v1 : A} → {t t1 t2 : bt A}
+          → k < key →  replacedTree key value t2 t →  replacedTree key value (node k v1 t1 t2) (node k v1 t1 t) 
+    r-left : {k : ℕ } {v1 : A} → {t t1 t2 : bt A}
+          → key < k →  replacedTree key value t1 t →  replacedTree key value (node k v1 t1 t2) (node k v1 t t2) 
+
+add< : { i : ℕ } (j : ℕ ) → i < suc i + j
+add<  {i} j = begin
+        suc i ≤⟨ m≤m+n (suc i) j ⟩
+        suc i + j ∎  where open ≤-Reasoning
+
+treeTest1  : bt ℕ
+treeTest1  =  node 0 0 leaf (node 3 1 (node 2 5 (node 1 7 leaf leaf ) leaf) (node 5 5 leaf leaf))
+treeTest2  : bt ℕ
+treeTest2  =  node 3 1 (node 2 5 (node 1 7 leaf leaf ) leaf) (node 5 5 leaf leaf)
+
+treeInvariantTest1  : treeInvariant treeTest1
+treeInvariantTest1  = t-right (m≤m+n _ 2) (t-node (add< 0) (add< 1) (t-left (add< 0) (t-single 1 7)) (t-single 5 5) )
+
+stack-top :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} (stack  : List (bt A)) → Maybe (bt A)
+stack-top [] = nothing
+stack-top (x ∷ s) = just x
+
+stack-last :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} (stack  : List (bt A)) → Maybe (bt A)
+stack-last [] = nothing
+stack-last (x ∷ []) = just x
+stack-last (x ∷ s) = stack-last s
+
+stackInvariantTest1 : stackInvariant 4 treeTest2 treeTest1 ( treeTest2 ∷ treeTest1 ∷ [] )
+stackInvariantTest1 = s-right (add< 3) (s-single  )
+
+si-property0 :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} {key : ℕ} {tree tree0 : bt A} → {stack  : List (bt A)} →  stackInvariant key tree tree0 stack → ¬ ( stack ≡ [] )
+si-property0  (s-single  ) ()
+si-property0  (s-right x si) ()
+si-property0  (s-left x si) ()
+
+si-property1 :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} {key : ℕ} {tree tree0 tree1 : bt A} → {stack  : List (bt A)} →  stackInvariant key tree tree0 (tree1 ∷ stack)
+   → tree1 ≡ tree
+si-property1 (s-single   ) = refl
+si-property1 (s-right _  si) = refl
+si-property1 (s-left _  si) = refl
+
+si-property-last :  {n : Level} {A : Set n}  (key : ℕ) (tree tree0 : bt A) → (stack  : List (bt A)) →  stackInvariant key tree tree0 stack
+   → stack-last stack ≡ just tree0
+si-property-last key t t0 (t ∷ [])  (s-single )  = refl
+si-property-last key t t0 (.t ∷ x ∷ st) (s-right _ si ) with  si-property1 si
+... | refl = si-property-last key x t0 (x ∷ st)   si
+si-property-last key t t0 (.t ∷ x ∷ st) (s-left _ si ) with  si-property1  si
+... | refl = si-property-last key x t0 (x ∷ st)   si
+
+ti-right : {n  : Level} {A : Set n} {tree₁ repl : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ} → {v1 : A} →  treeInvariant  (node key₁ v1 tree₁ repl) → treeInvariant repl
+ti-right {_} {_} {.leaf} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-single .key₁ .v1) = t-leaf
+ti-right {_} {_} {.leaf} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-right x ti) = ti
+ti-right {_} {_} {.(node _ _ _ _)} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-left x ti) = t-leaf
+ti-right {_} {_} {.(node _ _ _ _)} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) = ti₁
+
+ti-left : {n  : Level} {A : Set n} {tree₁ repl : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ} → {v1 : A} →  treeInvariant  (node key₁ v1 repl tree₁ ) → treeInvariant repl
+ti-left {_} {_} {.leaf} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-single .key₁ .v1) = t-leaf
+ti-left {_} {_} {_} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-right x ti) = t-leaf
+ti-left {_} {_} {_} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-left x ti) = ti
+ti-left {_} {_} {.(node _ _ _ _)} {_} {key₁} {v1} (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) = ti
+
+stackTreeInvariant : {n  : Level} {A : Set n} (key : ℕ) (sub tree : bt A) → (stack : List (bt A))
+   →  treeInvariant tree → stackInvariant key sub tree stack  → treeInvariant sub
+stackTreeInvariant {_} {A} key sub tree (sub ∷ []) ti (s-single  ) = ti
+stackTreeInvariant {_} {A} key sub tree (sub ∷ st) ti (s-right _ si ) = ti-right (si1 si) where
+   si1 : {tree₁ : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ} → {v1 : A} →  stackInvariant key (node key₁ v1 tree₁ sub ) tree st → treeInvariant  (node key₁ v1 tree₁ sub )
+   si1 {tree₁ }  {key₁ }  {v1 }  si = stackTreeInvariant  key (node key₁ v1 tree₁ sub ) tree st ti si
+stackTreeInvariant {_} {A} key sub tree (sub ∷ st) ti (s-left _ si ) = ti-left ( si2 si) where
+   si2 : {tree₁ : bt A} → {key₁ : ℕ} → {v1 : A} →  stackInvariant key (node key₁ v1 sub tree₁ ) tree st → treeInvariant  (node key₁ v1 sub tree₁ )
+   si2 {tree₁ }  {key₁ }  {v1 }  si = stackTreeInvariant  key (node key₁ v1 sub tree₁ ) tree st ti si
+
+rt-property1 :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} (key : ℕ) (value : A) (tree tree1 : bt A ) → replacedTree key value tree tree1 → ¬ ( tree1 ≡ leaf )
+rt-property1 {n} {A} key value .leaf .(node key value leaf leaf) r-leaf ()
+rt-property1 {n} {A} key value .(node key _ _ _) .(node key value _ _) r-node ()
+rt-property1 {n} {A} key value .(node _ _ _ _) _ (r-right x rt) = λ ()
+rt-property1 {n} {A} key value .(node _ _ _ _) _ (r-left x rt) = λ ()
+
+rt-property-leaf : {n : Level} {A : Set n} {key : ℕ} {value : A} {repl : bt A} → replacedTree key value leaf repl → repl ≡ node key value leaf leaf
+rt-property-leaf r-leaf = refl
+
+rt-property-¬leaf : {n : Level} {A : Set n} {key : ℕ} {value : A} {tree : bt A} → ¬ replacedTree key value tree leaf 
+rt-property-¬leaf ()
+
+rt-property-key : {n : Level} {A : Set n} {key key₂ key₃ : ℕ} {value value₂ value₃ : A} {left left₁ right₂ right₃ : bt A}
+    →  replacedTree key value (node key₂ value₂ left right₂) (node key₃ value₃ left₁ right₃) → key₂ ≡ key₃
+rt-property-key r-node = refl
+rt-property-key (r-right x ri) = refl
+rt-property-key (r-left x ri) = refl
+
+nat-≤> : { x y : ℕ } → x ≤ y → y < x → ⊥
+nat-≤>  (s≤s x<y) (s≤s y<x) = nat-≤> x<y y<x
+nat-<> : { x y : ℕ } → x < y → y < x → ⊥
+nat-<>  (s≤s x<y) (s≤s y<x) = nat-<> x<y y<x
+
+open _∧_
+
+
+depth-1< : {i j : ℕ} →   suc i ≤ suc (i Data.Nat.⊔ j )
+depth-1< {i} {j} = s≤s (m≤m⊔n _ j)
+
+depth-2< : {i j : ℕ} →   suc i ≤ suc (j Data.Nat.⊔ i )
+depth-2< {i} {j} = s≤s (m≤n⊔m j i)
+
+depth-3< : {i : ℕ } → suc i ≤ suc (suc i)
+depth-3< {zero} = s≤s ( z≤n )
+depth-3< {suc i} = s≤s (depth-3< {i} )
+
+
+treeLeftDown  : {n : Level} {A : Set n} {k : ℕ} {v1 : A}  → (tree tree₁ : bt A )
+      → treeInvariant (node k v1 tree tree₁)
+      →      treeInvariant tree 
+treeLeftDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} leaf leaf (t-single k1 v1) = t-leaf
+treeLeftDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .leaf .(node _ _ _ _) (t-right x ti) = t-leaf
+treeLeftDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .(node _ _ _ _) .leaf (t-left x ti) = ti 
+treeLeftDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .(node _ _ _ _) .(node _ _ _ _) (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) = ti
+
+treeRightDown  : {n : Level} {A : Set n} {k : ℕ} {v1 : A}  → (tree tree₁ : bt A )
+      → treeInvariant (node k v1 tree tree₁)
+      →      treeInvariant tree₁ 
+treeRightDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .leaf .leaf (t-single _ .v1) = t-leaf
+treeRightDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .leaf .(node _ _ _ _) (t-right x ti) = ti
+treeRightDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .(node _ _ _ _) .leaf (t-left x ti) = t-leaf
+treeRightDown {n} {A} {_} {v1} .(node _ _ _ _) .(node _ _ _ _) (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) = ti₁
+
+findP : {n m : Level} {A : Set n} {t : Set m} → (key : ℕ) → (tree tree0 : bt A ) → (stack : List (bt A))
+           →  treeInvariant tree ∧ stackInvariant key tree tree0 stack  
+           → (next : (tree1 : bt A) → (stack : List (bt A)) → treeInvariant tree1 ∧ stackInvariant key tree1 tree0 stack → bt-depth tree1 < bt-depth tree   → t )
+           → (exit : (tree1 : bt A) → (stack : List (bt A)) → treeInvariant tree1 ∧ stackInvariant key tree1 tree0 stack
+                 → (tree1 ≡ leaf ) ∨ ( node-key tree1 ≡ just key )  → t ) → t
+findP key leaf tree0 st Pre _ exit = exit leaf st Pre (case1 refl)
+findP key (node key₁ v1 tree tree₁) tree0 st Pre next exit with <-cmp key key₁
+findP key n tree0 st Pre _ exit | tri≈ ¬a refl ¬c = exit n st Pre (case2 refl)
+findP {n} {_} {A} key (node key₁ v1 tree tree₁) tree0 st  Pre next _ | tri< a ¬b ¬c = next tree (tree ∷ st)
+       ⟪ treeLeftDown tree tree₁ (proj1 Pre)  , findP1 a st (proj2 Pre) ⟫ depth-1< where
+   findP1 : key < key₁ → (st : List (bt A)) →  stackInvariant key (node key₁ v1 tree tree₁) tree0 st → stackInvariant key tree tree0 (tree ∷ st)
+   findP1 a (x ∷ st) si = s-left a si
+findP key n@(node key₁ v1 tree tree₁) tree0 st Pre next _ | tri> ¬a ¬b c = next tree₁ (tree₁ ∷ st) ⟪ treeRightDown tree tree₁ (proj1 Pre) , s-right c (proj2 Pre) ⟫ depth-2<
+
+replaceTree1 : {n  : Level} {A : Set n} {t t₁ : bt A } → ( k : ℕ ) → (v1 value : A ) →  treeInvariant (node k v1 t t₁) → treeInvariant (node k value t t₁)
+replaceTree1 k v1 value (t-single .k .v1) = t-single k value
+replaceTree1 k v1 value (t-right x t) = t-right x t
+replaceTree1 k v1 value (t-left x t) = t-left x t
+replaceTree1 k v1 value (t-node x x₁ t t₁) = t-node x x₁ t t₁
+
+open import Relation.Binary.Definitions
+
+lemma3 : {i j : ℕ} → 0 ≡ i → j < i → ⊥
+lemma3 refl ()
+lemma5 : {i j : ℕ} → i < 1 → j < i → ⊥
+lemma5 (s≤s z≤n) ()
+¬x<x : {x : ℕ} → ¬ (x < x)
+¬x<x (s≤s lt) = ¬x<x lt
+
+child-replaced :  {n : Level} {A : Set n} (key : ℕ)   (tree : bt A) → bt A
+child-replaced key leaf = leaf
+child-replaced key (node key₁ value left right) with <-cmp key key₁
+... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = left
+... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = node key₁ value left right
+... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = right
+
+record replacePR {n : Level} {A : Set n} (key : ℕ) (value : A) (tree repl : bt A ) (stack : List (bt A)) (C : bt A → bt A → List (bt A) → Set n) : Set n where
+   field
+     tree0 : bt A
+     ti : treeInvariant tree0
+     si : stackInvariant key tree tree0 stack
+     ri : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key tree ) repl
+     ci : C tree repl stack     -- data continuation
+   
+replaceNodeP : {n m : Level} {A : Set n} {t : Set m} → (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → (tree : bt A)
+    → (tree ≡ leaf ) ∨ ( node-key tree ≡ just key )
+    → (treeInvariant tree ) → ((tree1 : bt A) → treeInvariant tree1 →  replacedTree key value (child-replaced key tree) tree1 → t) → t
+replaceNodeP k v1 leaf C P next = next (node k v1 leaf leaf) (t-single k v1 ) r-leaf
+replaceNodeP k v1 (node .k value t t₁) (case2 refl) P next = next (node k v1 t t₁) (replaceTree1 k value v1 P)
+     (subst (λ j → replacedTree k v1 j  (node k v1 t t₁) ) repl00 r-node) where 
+         repl00 : node k value t t₁ ≡ child-replaced k (node k value t t₁)
+         repl00 with <-cmp k k
+         ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬b refl)
+         ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = refl
+         ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬b refl)
+
+replaceP : {n m : Level} {A : Set n} {t : Set m}
+     → (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → {tree : bt A} ( repl : bt A)
+     → (stack : List (bt A)) → replacePR key value tree repl stack (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤) 
+     → (next : ℕ → A → {tree1 : bt A } (repl : bt A) → (stack1 : List (bt A))
+         → replacePR key value tree1 repl stack1 (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤) → length stack1 < length stack → t)
+     → (exit : (tree1 repl : bt A) → treeInvariant tree1 ∧ replacedTree key value tree1 repl → t) → t
+replaceP key value {tree}  repl [] Pre next exit = ⊥-elim ( si-property0 (replacePR.si Pre) refl ) -- can't happen
+replaceP key value {tree}  repl (leaf ∷ []) Pre next exit with  si-property-last  _ _ _ _  (replacePR.si Pre)-- tree0 ≡ leaf
+... | refl  =  exit (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (node key value leaf leaf) ⟪ replacePR.ti Pre ,  r-leaf ⟫
+replaceP key value {tree}  repl (node key₁ value₁ left right ∷ []) Pre next exit with <-cmp key key₁
+... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = exit (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (node key₁ value₁ repl right ) ⟪ replacePR.ti Pre , repl01 ⟫ where
+    repl01 : replacedTree key value (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (node key₁ value₁ repl right )
+    repl01 with si-property1 (replacePR.si Pre) | si-property-last  _ _ _ _  (replacePR.si Pre)   
+    repl01 | refl | refl = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value  (node key₁ value₁ k right ) (node key₁ value₁ repl right )) repl02 (r-left a repl03) where
+        repl03 : replacedTree key value ( child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) repl
+        repl03 = replacePR.ri Pre
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ left
+        repl02 with <-cmp key key₁
+        ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = refl 
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬a a)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim ( ¬a a)
+... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = exit (replacePR.tree0 Pre) repl ⟪ replacePR.ti Pre , repl01 ⟫ where
+    repl01 : replacedTree key value (replacePR.tree0 Pre) repl  
+    repl01 with si-property1 (replacePR.si Pre) | si-property-last  _ _ _ _  (replacePR.si Pre)   
+    repl01 | refl | refl = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k repl) repl02 (replacePR.ri Pre) where
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ node key₁ value₁ left right
+        repl02 with <-cmp key key₁
+        ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬b b)
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = refl
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim ( ¬b b)
+... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = exit (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (node key₁ value₁ left repl  ) ⟪ replacePR.ti Pre , repl01 ⟫ where
+    repl01 : replacedTree key value (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (node key₁ value₁ left repl )
+    repl01 with si-property1 (replacePR.si Pre) | si-property-last  _ _ _ _  (replacePR.si Pre)   
+    repl01 | refl | refl = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value  (node key₁ value₁ left k ) (node key₁ value₁ left repl )) repl02 (r-right c repl03) where
+        repl03 : replacedTree key value ( child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) repl
+        repl03 = replacePR.ri Pre
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ right
+        repl02 with <-cmp key key₁
+        ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬c c)
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim ( ¬c c)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl 
+replaceP {n} {_} {A} key value  {tree}  repl (leaf ∷ st@(tree1 ∷ st1)) Pre next exit = next key value repl st Post ≤-refl where
+    Post :  replacePR key value tree1 repl (tree1 ∷ st1) (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤)
+    Post with replacePR.si Pre 
+    ... | s-right  {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} x si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 tree₁ leaf
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl07 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 tree₁ leaf) ≡ leaf
+        repl07 with <-cmp key key₂ 
+        ... |  tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c x)
+        ... |  tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c x)
+        ... |  tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) repl
+        repl12 = subst₂ (λ j k → replacedTree key value j k ) (sym (subst (λ k → child-replaced key k ≡ leaf) (sym repl09) repl07 ) ) (sym (rt-property-leaf (replacePR.ri Pre))) r-leaf
+    ... | s-left  {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} x si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 leaf tree₁ 
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl07 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 leaf tree₁ ) ≡ leaf
+        repl07 with <-cmp key key₂ 
+        ... |  tri< a ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... |  tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a x)
+        ... |  tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a x)
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) repl
+        repl12 = subst₂ (λ j k → replacedTree key value j k ) (sym (subst (λ k → child-replaced key k ≡ leaf) (sym repl09) repl07 ) ) (sym (rt-property-leaf (replacePR.ri Pre))) r-leaf
+replaceP {n} {_} {A} key value {tree}  repl (node key₁ value₁ left right ∷ st@(tree1 ∷ st1)) Pre next exit  with <-cmp key key₁ 
+... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = next key value (node key₁ value₁ repl right ) st Post ≤-refl where
+    Post : replacePR key value tree1 (node key₁ value₁ repl right ) st (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤) 
+    Post with replacePR.si Pre 
+    ... | s-right {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} lt si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) 
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl03 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ left
+        repl03 with <-cmp key key₁ 
+        ... | tri< a1 ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a a)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a a)
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) ) ≡ node key₁ value₁ left right
+        repl02 with repl09 | <-cmp key key₂
+        ... | refl | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c lt)
+        ... | refl | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c lt)
+        ... | refl | tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl
+        repl04 : node key₁ value₁ (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) right ≡ child-replaced key tree1
+        repl04  = begin
+            node key₁ value₁ (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) right ≡⟨ cong (λ k → node key₁ value₁ k right) repl03  ⟩
+            node key₁ value₁ left right ≡⟨ sym repl02 ⟩
+            child-replaced key  (node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) ) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → child-replaced key k ) (sym repl09) ⟩
+            child-replaced key tree1 ∎  where open ≡-Reasoning
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value₁ repl right)
+        repl12 = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value₁ repl right) ) repl04  (r-left a (replacePR.ri Pre)) 
+    ... | s-left {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} lt si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁  
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl03 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ left
+        repl03 with <-cmp key key₁ 
+        ... | tri< a1 ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a a)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a a)
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁) ≡ node key₁ value₁ left right
+        repl02 with repl09 | <-cmp key key₂
+        ... | refl | tri< a ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... | refl | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a lt)
+        ... | refl | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a lt)
+        repl04 : node key₁ value₁ (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) right ≡ child-replaced key tree1
+        repl04  = begin
+            node key₁ value₁ (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) right ≡⟨ cong (λ k → node key₁ value₁ k right) repl03  ⟩
+            node key₁ value₁ left right ≡⟨ sym repl02 ⟩
+            child-replaced key  (node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → child-replaced key k ) (sym repl09) ⟩
+            child-replaced key tree1 ∎  where open ≡-Reasoning
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value₁ repl right)
+        repl12 = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value₁ repl right) ) repl04  (r-left a (replacePR.ri Pre)) 
+... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = next key value (node key₁ value  left right ) st Post ≤-refl where 
+    Post :  replacePR key value tree1 (node key₁ value left right ) (tree1 ∷ st1) (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤)
+    Post with replacePR.si Pre 
+    ... | s-right  {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} x si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 b ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 tree₁ tree -- (node key₁ value₁  left right)
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl07 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 tree₁ tree) ≡ tree
+        repl07 with <-cmp key key₂ 
+        ... |  tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c x)
+        ... |  tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c x)
+        ... |  tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl
+        repl12 : (key ≡ key₁) → replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value left right )
+        repl12 refl with repl09 
+        ... | refl = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value left right )) (sym repl07) r-node
+    ... | s-left  {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} x si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 b ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 tree tree₁ 
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl07 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 tree tree₁ ) ≡ tree
+        repl07 with <-cmp key key₂ 
+        ... |  tri< a ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... |  tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a x)
+        ... |  tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a x)
+        repl12 : (key ≡ key₁) → replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value left right )
+        repl12 refl with repl09 
+        ... | refl = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value left right )) (sym repl07) r-node
+... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = next key value (node key₁ value₁ left repl ) st Post ≤-refl where
+    Post : replacePR key value tree1 (node key₁ value₁ left repl ) st (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤) 
+    Post with replacePR.si Pre 
+    ... | s-right {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} lt si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) 
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl03 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ right
+        repl03 with <-cmp key key₁ 
+        ... | tri< a1 ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c c)
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c c)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl 
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) ) ≡ node key₁ value₁ left right
+        repl02 with repl09 | <-cmp key key₂
+        ... | refl | tri< a ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c lt)
+        ... | refl | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c lt)
+        ... | refl | tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl
+        repl04 : node key₁ value₁ left (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) ≡ child-replaced key tree1
+        repl04  = begin
+            node key₁ value₁ left (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → node key₁ value₁ left k ) repl03 ⟩
+            node key₁ value₁ left right ≡⟨ sym repl02 ⟩
+            child-replaced key  (node key₂ v1 tree₁ (node key₁ value₁ left right) ) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → child-replaced key k ) (sym repl09) ⟩
+            child-replaced key tree1 ∎  where open ≡-Reasoning
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value₁ left repl)
+        repl12 = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value₁ left repl) ) repl04 (r-right c (replacePR.ri Pre)) 
+    ... | s-left {_} {_} {tree₁} {key₂} {v1} lt si = record { tree0 = replacePR.tree0 Pre ; ti = replacePR.ti Pre ; si = repl10 ; ri = repl12 ; ci = lift tt } where
+        repl09 : tree1 ≡ node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁  
+        repl09 = si-property1 si
+        repl10 : stackInvariant key tree1 (replacePR.tree0 Pre) (tree1 ∷ st1)
+        repl10 with si-property1 si
+        ... | refl = si
+        repl03 : child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right) ≡ right
+        repl03 with <-cmp key key₁ 
+        ... | tri< a1 ¬b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c c)
+        ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬c c)
+        ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c = refl 
+        repl02 : child-replaced key (node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁) ≡ node key₁ value₁ left right
+        repl02 with repl09 | <-cmp key key₂
+        ... | refl | tri< a ¬b ¬c = refl
+        ... | refl | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = ⊥-elim (¬a lt)
+        ... | refl | tri> ¬a ¬b c = ⊥-elim (¬a lt)
+        repl04 : node key₁ value₁ left (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) ≡ child-replaced key tree1
+        repl04  = begin
+            node key₁ value₁ left (child-replaced key (node key₁ value₁ left right)) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → node key₁ value₁ left k ) repl03 ⟩
+            node key₁ value₁ left right ≡⟨ sym repl02 ⟩
+            child-replaced key  (node key₂ v1 (node key₁ value₁ left right) tree₁) ≡⟨ cong (λ k → child-replaced key k ) (sym repl09) ⟩
+            child-replaced key tree1 ∎  where open ≡-Reasoning
+        repl12 : replacedTree key value (child-replaced key  tree1  ) (node key₁ value₁ left repl)
+        repl12 = subst (λ k → replacedTree key value k (node key₁ value₁ left repl) ) repl04  (r-right c (replacePR.ri Pre)) 
+
+TerminatingLoopS : {l m : Level} {t : Set l} (Index : Set m ) → {Invraiant : Index → Set m } → ( reduce : Index → ℕ)
+   → (r : Index) → (p : Invraiant r)  
+   → (loop : (r : Index)  → Invraiant r → (next : (r1 : Index)  → Invraiant r1 → reduce r1 < reduce r  → t ) → t) → t
+TerminatingLoopS {_} {_} {t} Index {Invraiant} reduce r p loop with <-cmp 0 (reduce r)
+... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = loop r p (λ r1 p1 lt → ⊥-elim (lemma3 b lt) ) 
+... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = loop r p (λ r1 p1 lt1 → TerminatingLoop1 (reduce r) r r1 (≤-step lt1) p1 lt1 ) where 
+    TerminatingLoop1 : (j : ℕ) → (r r1 : Index) → reduce r1 < suc j  → Invraiant r1 →  reduce r1 < reduce r → t
+    TerminatingLoop1 zero r r1 n≤j p1 lt = loop r1 p1 (λ r2 p1 lt1 → ⊥-elim (lemma5 n≤j lt1)) 
+    TerminatingLoop1 (suc j) r r1  n≤j p1 lt with <-cmp (reduce r1) (suc j)
+    ... | tri< a ¬b ¬c = TerminatingLoop1 j r r1 a p1 lt 
+    ... | tri≈ ¬a b ¬c = loop r1 p1 (λ r2 p2 lt1 → TerminatingLoop1 j r1 r2 (subst (λ k → reduce r2 < k ) b lt1 ) p2 lt1 )
+    ... | tri> ¬a ¬b c =  ⊥-elim ( nat-≤> c n≤j )   
+
+open _∧_
+
+RTtoTI0  : {n : Level} {A : Set n}  → (tree repl : bt A) → (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → treeInvariant tree
+     → replacedTree key value tree repl → treeInvariant repl
+RTtoTI0 .leaf .(node key value leaf leaf) key value ti r-leaf = t-single key value
+RTtoTI0 .(node key _ leaf leaf) .(node key value leaf leaf) key value (t-single .key _) r-node = t-single key value
+RTtoTI0 .(node key _ leaf (node _ _ _ _)) .(node key value leaf (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x ti) r-node = t-right x ti 
+RTtoTI0 .(node key _ (node _ _ _ _) leaf) .(node key value (node _ _ _ _) leaf) key value (t-left x ti) r-node = t-left x ti 
+RTtoTI0 .(node key _ (node _ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) .(node key value (node _ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) r-node = t-node x x₁ ti ti₁
+-- r-right case
+RTtoTI0 (node _ _ leaf leaf) (node _ _ leaf .(node key value leaf leaf)) key value (t-single _ _) (r-right x r-leaf) = t-right x (t-single key value)
+RTtoTI0 (node _ _ leaf right@(node _ _ _ _)) (node key₁ value₁ leaf leaf) key value (t-right x₁ ti) (r-right x ri) = t-single key₁ value₁
+RTtoTI0 (node key₁ _ leaf right@(node key₂ _ _ _)) (node key₁ value₁ leaf right₁@(node key₃ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x₁ ti) (r-right x ri) = 
+      t-right (subst (λ k → key₁ < k ) (rt-property-key ri) x₁) (RTtoTI0 _ _ key value ti ri)
+RTtoTI0 (node key₁ _ (node _ _ _ _) leaf) (node key₁ _ (node key₃ value left right) leaf) key value₁ (t-left x₁ ti) (r-right x ())
+RTtoTI0 (node key₁ _ (node key₃ _ _ _) leaf) (node key₁ _ (node key₃ value₃ _ _) (node key value leaf leaf)) key value (t-left x₁ ti) (r-right x r-leaf) =
+      t-node x₁ x ti (t-single key value) 
+RTtoTI0 (node key₁ _ (node _ _ _ _) (node key₂ _ _ _)) (node key₁ _ (node _ _ _ _) (node key₃ _ _ _)) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-right x ri) =
+      t-node x₁ (subst (λ k → key₁ < k) (rt-property-key ri) x₂) ti (RTtoTI0 _ _ key value ti₁ ri)
+-- r-left case
+RTtoTI0 .(node _ _ leaf leaf) .(node _ _ (node key value leaf leaf) leaf) key value (t-single _ _) (r-left x r-leaf) = t-left x (t-single _ _ )
+RTtoTI0 .(node _ _ leaf (node _ _ _ _)) (node key₁ value₁ (node key value leaf leaf) (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x₁ ti) (r-left x r-leaf) = t-node x x₁ (t-single key value) ti
+RTtoTI0 (node key₃ _ (node key₂ _ _ _) leaf) (node key₃ _ (node key₁ value₁ left left₁) leaf) key value (t-left x₁ ti) (r-left x ri) =
+      t-left (subst (λ k → k < key₃ ) (rt-property-key ri) x₁) (RTtoTI0 _ _ key value ti ri) -- key₁ < key₃
+RTtoTI0 (node key₁ _ (node key₂ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) (node key₁ _ (node key₃ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-left x ri) = t-node (subst (λ k → k < key₁ ) (rt-property-key ri) x₁) x₂  (RTtoTI0 _ _ key value ti ri) ti₁
+
+RTtoTI1  : {n : Level} {A : Set n}  → (tree repl : bt A) → (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → treeInvariant repl
+     → replacedTree key value tree repl → treeInvariant tree
+RTtoTI1 .leaf .(node key value leaf leaf) key value ti r-leaf = t-leaf
+RTtoTI1 (node key value₁ leaf leaf) .(node key value leaf leaf) key value (t-single .key .value) r-node = t-single key value₁
+RTtoTI1 .(node key _ leaf (node _ _ _ _)) .(node key value leaf (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x ti) r-node = t-right x ti
+RTtoTI1 .(node key _ (node _ _ _ _) leaf) .(node key value (node _ _ _ _) leaf) key value (t-left x ti) r-node = t-left x ti
+RTtoTI1 .(node key _ (node _ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) .(node key value (node _ _ _ _) (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-node x x₁ ti ti₁) r-node = t-node x x₁ ti ti₁
+-- r-right case
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ value₁ leaf leaf) (node key₁ _ leaf (node _ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x₁ ti) (r-right x r-leaf) = t-single key₁ value₁
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ value₁ leaf (node key₂ value₂ t2 t3)) (node key₁ _ leaf (node key₃ _ _ _)) key value (t-right x₁ ti) (r-right x ri) =
+   t-right (subst (λ k → key₁ < k ) (sym (rt-property-key ri)) x₁)  (RTtoTI1 _ _ key value ti ri) -- key₁ < key₂
+RTtoTI1 (node _ _ (node _ _ _ _) leaf) (node _ _ (node _ _ _ _) (node key value _ _)) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-right x r-leaf) =
+    t-left x₁ ti
+RTtoTI1 (node key₄ _ (node key₃ _ _ _) (node key₁ value₁ n n₁)) (node key₄ _ (node key₃ _ _ _) (node key₂ _ _ _)) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-right x ri) = t-node x₁ (subst (λ k → key₄ < k ) (sym (rt-property-key ri)) x₂) ti (RTtoTI1 _ _ key value ti₁ ri) -- key₄ < key₁
+-- r-left case
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ value₁ leaf leaf) (node key₁ _ _ leaf) key value (t-left x₁ ti) (r-left x ri) = t-single key₁ value₁
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ _ (node key₂ value₁ n n₁) leaf) (node key₁ _ (node key₃ _ _ _) leaf) key value (t-left x₁ ti) (r-left x ri) = 
+   t-left (subst (λ k → k < key₁ ) (sym (rt-property-key ri)) x₁) (RTtoTI1 _ _ key value ti ri) -- key₂ < key₁
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ value₁ leaf _) (node key₁ _ _ _) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-left x r-leaf) = t-right x₂ ti₁
+RTtoTI1 (node key₁ value₁ (node key₂ value₂ n n₁) _) (node key₁ _ _ _) key value (t-node x₁ x₂ ti ti₁) (r-left x ri) = 
+    t-node (subst (λ k → k < key₁ ) (sym (rt-property-key ri)) x₁) x₂ (RTtoTI1 _ _ key value ti ri) ti₁ -- key₂ < key₁
+
+insertTreeP : {n m : Level} {A : Set n} {t : Set m} → (tree : bt A) → (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → treeInvariant tree
+     → (exit : (tree repl : bt A) → treeInvariant repl ∧ replacedTree key value tree repl → t ) → t
+insertTreeP {n} {m} {A} {t} tree key value P0 exit =
+   TerminatingLoopS (bt A ∧ List (bt A) ) {λ p → treeInvariant (proj1 p) ∧ stackInvariant key (proj1 p) tree (proj2 p) } (λ p → bt-depth (proj1 p)) ⟪ tree , tree ∷ [] ⟫  ⟪ P0 , s-single ⟫
+       $ λ p P loop → findP key (proj1 p)  tree (proj2 p) P (λ t s P1 lt → loop ⟪ t ,  s  ⟫ P1 lt ) 
+       $ λ t s P C → replaceNodeP key value t C (proj1 P)
+       $ λ t1 P1 R → TerminatingLoopS (List (bt A) ∧ bt A ∧ bt A )
+            {λ p → replacePR key value  (proj1 (proj2 p)) (proj2 (proj2 p)) (proj1 p)  (λ _ _ _ → Lift n ⊤ ) }
+               (λ p → length (proj1 p)) ⟪ s , ⟪ t , t1 ⟫ ⟫ record { tree0 = tree ; ti = P0 ; si = proj2 P ; ri = R ; ci = lift tt } 
+       $  λ p P1 loop → replaceP key value  (proj2 (proj2 p)) (proj1 p) P1
+            (λ key value {tree1} repl1 stack P2 lt → loop ⟪ stack , ⟪ tree1 , repl1  ⟫ ⟫ P2 lt )
+       $ λ tree repl P →  exit tree repl ⟪ RTtoTI0 _ _ _ _ (proj1 P) (proj2 P) , proj2 P ⟫   
+
+insertTestP1 = insertTreeP leaf 1 1 t-leaf
+  $ λ _ x0 P0 → insertTreeP x0 2 1 (proj1 P0) 
+  $ λ _ x1 P1 → insertTreeP x1 3 2 (proj1 P1)  
+  $ λ _ x2 P2 → insertTreeP x2 2 2 (proj1 P2) (λ _ x _  → x )
+
+top-value : {n : Level} {A : Set n} → (tree : bt A) →  Maybe A 
+top-value leaf = nothing
+top-value (node key value tree tree₁) = just value
+
+-- is realy inserted?
+
+-- other element is preserved?
+
+-- deletion?
+
+data Color  : Set where
+    Red : Color
+    Black : Color
+
+data rbInvariant {n : Level} {A : Set n} : bt A → Color → ℕ → Set n where
+    rb-leaf     : rbInvariant leaf Black 0
+    rb-single   : (key : ℕ) → (value : A) → (c : Color) →  rbInvariant (node key value leaf leaf) c 1
+    t-right-red : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → {d : ℕ } → rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂) Black d
+       → rbInvariant (node key value leaf (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂)) Red d
+    t-right-black : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → {c : Color} → {d : ℕ }→ rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂) c d
+       → rbInvariant (node key value leaf (node key₁ value₁ t₁ t₂)) Black (suc d)
+    t-left-red  : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → {d : ℕ} → rbInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂) Black d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) leaf ) Red d
+    t-left-black  : {key key₁ : ℕ} → {value value₁ : A} → {t₁ t₂ : bt A} → {c : Color} → {d : ℕ}  → rbInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂) c d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) leaf ) Black (suc d)
+    t-node-red  : {key key₁ key₂ : ℕ} → {value value₁ value₂ : A} → {t₁ t₂ t₃ t₄ : bt A} {d : ℕ}
+       → rbInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂) Black d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄) Black d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄)) Red d
+    t-node-black  : {key key₁ key₂ : ℕ} → {value value₁ value₂ : A} → {t₁ t₂ t₃ t₄ : bt A} {c c1 : Color} {d : ℕ}
+       → rbInvariant (node key value t₁ t₂) c d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄) c1 d
+       → rbInvariant (node key₁ value₁ (node key value t₁ t₂) (node key₂ value₂ t₃ t₄)) Black (suc d)
+
--- a/redBlackTreeHoare.agda	Sun May 22 19:07:20 2022 +0900
+++ b/redBlackTreeHoare.agda	Sun Apr 09 17:15:42 2023 +0900
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
 open import Data.Nat hiding (compare)
 open import Data.Nat.Properties as NatProp
 open import Data.Maybe
-open import Data.Bool
+open import Data.Bool hiding ( _<_ )
 open import Data.Empty
 
 open import Relation.Binary